Thermal reactors and fast neutron reactors differ in their neutron energy spectrum, use of moderators, coolants, fuel types, and safety and proliferation concerns.
2 / 2
Thermal Reactors vs. Fast Neutron Reactors: Understanding the Differences
Nuclear reactors are the core of any nuclear power plant, converting nuclear energy into electrical energy. There are various types of nuclear reactors, with the primary distinction being between thermal reactors and fast neutron reactors. This article provides an overview of the key differences between these two reactor types.
Neutron Spectrum: Thermal vs. Fast Neutrons
The primary difference between thermal reactors and fast neutron reactors lies in the energy spectrum of the neutrons involved in the fission process. In thermal reactors, neutrons are slowed down to thermal energies (low energies) through a process known as moderation. In contrast, fast neutron reactors use high-energy neutrons, which are not moderated, to sustain the fission chain reaction.
Moderators and Coolants
Thermal reactors require a moderator to slow down neutrons to thermal energies, thus increasing the likelihood of fission. Common moderators include light water, heavy water, and graphite. In contrast, fast neutron reactors do not use moderators, as they rely on high-energy neutrons for fission.
Coolants are used in both types of reactors to remove heat generated by the fission process. While light water is the most common coolant for thermal reactors, fast neutron reactors typically use liquid metals, such as sodium or lead, due to their high thermal conductivity and compatibility with fast neutrons.
Fuel Utilization
- Thermal Reactors: Most thermal reactors use low-enriched uranium (LEU) as fuel, which contains a relatively low concentration of the fissile isotope U-235. This fuel is widely available and less proliferation-sensitive compared to highly enriched uranium (HEU).
- Fast Neutron Reactors: Fast reactors can utilize a wider range of fuels, including plutonium, minor actinides, and depleted uranium. They can also “breed” fissile material by converting fertile isotopes, such as U-238, into plutonium-239 through a process called breeding. This capability allows fast reactors to generate more fuel than they consume, making them more resource-efficient.
Safety and Proliferation Concerns
Thermal reactors generally have lower power densities and more negative reactivity coefficients, making them inherently safer in some respects. However, fast neutron reactors offer passive safety features, such as a strong negative temperature coefficient, that can enhance safety as well.
While thermal reactors pose fewer proliferation risks due to their use of low-enriched uranium, fast neutron reactors’ ability to breed fissile material has raised proliferation concerns. To address these concerns, advanced fast reactor designs incorporate proliferation-resistant features and focus on closing the nuclear fuel cycle in a safe and secure manner.
Conclusion
In summary, thermal reactors and fast neutron reactors differ in their neutron energy spectrum, use of moderators, coolants, fuel types, and safety and proliferation concerns. Each type of reactor offers distinct advantages and challenges, and the choice between them depends on factors such as resource availability, national policies, and long-term energy strategies.